Escaping Orthodoxy: Katrin’s Journey from Ultra-Orthodox Judaism to Secular Life

In this revealing episode, ‘Katrin’ shares her experiences growing up in an ultra-Orthodox Jewish community in England. She discusses the unique challenges of her upbringing in a restrictive religious environment characterized by lower-income neighborhood struggles. Katrin opens up about her nonconformity, neurodivergence, and queerness, which made her feel like an outcast from a very young age.

Her narrative delves into her eventual departure from the community, including her time in Israel, and the subsequent challenges and victories in building a life outside the religious framework. The discussion also touches upon broader themes of religious disillusionment, mental health, and the essential quest for a supportive, understanding community.

00:00 Introduction and Guest Background
00:36 Growing Up in a Religious Community
03:31 Struggles with Identity and Religion
06:30 Neurodivergence and Religious Constructs
09:29 Queer Experiences in a Religious Setting
14:10 Leaving Religion and Its Consequences
18:34 Journey Out of Religion
32:41 Transitioning to Social Care
33:33 Navigating Education and Funding
34:15 Family Support and University Decision
34:42 Reflecting on Career Choices
34:53 Self-Education Through Psychology
36:01 Balancing Practical Skills and Professional Growth
36:50 Personal Identity and Family Dynamics
37:45 Challenges of Leaving Religion
38:19 Unlearning Prejudices and Embracing Diversity
41:20 Navigating Safety and Privilege
44:35 Building Community and Finding Meaning
55:03 Advice for Those Leaving Religion
59:04 Interviewer’s Reflections and Common Themes

Episode Summary

In this powerful and introspective episode, we delve into the captivating story of Katrin, a pseudonym chosen to guard anonymity, as she shares her journey out of an ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. In this episode they explore themes of identity, community, mental health, and survival after leaving a strict religious environment.

Early Life and The Struggle for Belonging

Katrin’s story begins in the densely packed corridors of an ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. Despite growing up amidst religious fervor, she always felt like an outsider, a sentiment many can resonate with. “I was being pointed out as different before I even realized I was different,” Katrin recounts. Raised in a highly religious neighborhood, she was one of many children in an isolated and insular community, surrounded by strict religious norms and values.

Katrin’s experience highlights the struggles of growing up queer in a deeply conservative society. “Being queer, in terms of life, sexuality, and being what is not acceptable or normal,” Katrin explains, compounded her sense of not fitting in. This misalignment with both the religious teachings and the societal constructs around her shaped much of her early years and her eventual decision to leave the community.

The Religious Exodus and Mental Health

Katrin’s journey out was tumultuous and fraught with challenges. “I got kicked out of school,” she says, an event which paradoxically helped her to transition away from the religious constraints that bound her. Eventually, she found herself in Israel, a place she describes as having offered her a semblance of structure and stability amidst the chaos. “Having the option of a structure for a while, I think really worked for my brain,” she explains.

Mental health issues are a recurring theme in Katrin’s narrative. From dealing with neurodiverse traits to coping with depression and suicidal thoughts, her story underscores the critical intersection between mental well-being and the process of leaving a restrictive religious background. Therapeutic interventions played a pivotal role in her recovery and adjustment to a new life outside her former community.

Finding Community After Religion

Community is a central theme in Katrin’s story. The ultra-Orthodox community she left was tightly knit but also stifling. Upon leaving, finding or creating a new, supportive community became crucial. Katrin emphasizes the importance of seeking out like-minded individuals and building new connections.

“Finding something that connects you,” she advises, is essential. Whether through painting, walking groups, or other shared interests, creating a new community can be a lifeline. Katrin found solace in the queer community, which provided her with support and understanding that she desperately needed. “Be willing to be rejected,” she encourages, stressing the importance of persistence in forming new bonds.

Overcoming Prejudices and Unlearning

One of the most compelling aspects of Katrin’s journey is her conscious effort to unlearn prejudices and internalized beliefs from her former religious life. “I had to specifically train myself out of being, I don’t want to say racist, because I don’t think we ever were, but we didn’t know any Black people,” she admits, highlighting the inherent biases she worked to dismantle.

Her process of unlearning extended to overcoming antisemitism and negative beliefs about young mothers, among other things. This self-awareness and dedication to personal growth exemplify the hard work required to rebuild one’s identity after leaving a life steeped in rigid ideologies.

Finding Meaning and Purpose

Katrin’s reflections on finding meaning post-religion are profound. She believes in the interconnectedness of humanity and the significance of emitting positive energy. “We are born with a purpose,” she states, advocating for living a life that contributes positively to the world. This spiritual, rather than religious, outlook has guided her to focus on self-improvement and community support.

Concluding Thoughts: Advice for Others

For those considering or navigating a similar journey, Katrin offers steadfast advice. Seek out and build a community based on shared interests or aspects of your identity that resonate with you. Whether it’s joining clubs or groups or simply reaching out to others, the key is to persist despite possible rejections.

Ultimately, Katrin’s story is one of resilience, self-awareness, and the search for belonging. It sheds light on the multifaceted challenges faced by those leaving strict religious communities and offers a beacon of hope and guidance for others on a similar path.


Katrin’s journey out of an ultra-Orthodox Jewish community into a life of more freedom and acceptance is not only inspirational but also educational. Her emphasis on community, personal growth, and the importance of mental health can serve as a guide for many struggling with their own paths to authenticity and self-acceptance.

Facebook Comments

More Episodes

Perpetuating Trauma

I was 11 or 12 years old when my school took us to the neighborhood holocaust museum (what, yours doesn’t have one?) The rabbis warned...

Modes of transportation

Some run towards the fire, Some run from it Some ride towards the end. Head held high, staunchly gripping the handlebars. Others try to speed away from...

Accounting

He never learned much math. Math was limited to two hours a week with a secular studies teacher who spent more time shouting at...
Previous article
Next article

Current Weather in Hell

Hell
overcast clouds
44.5 ° F
44.8 °
43.8 °
100 %
1.3mph
100 %
Wed
48 °
Thu
51 °
Fri
49 °
Sat
48 °
Sun
43 °

Even More Freidom

Chumash as an Instagram Post

I think I was still religious when I made these. The writing was on the wall. Facebook...

The Smiling Rabbi

Interesting anecdote about this book cover. It's a composite of two different Rabbi faces, i.e. it's not...

Something’s Gotta Give

My partner just came back from an eight-day silent meditation retreat. She remarked (with some jealousy) how...

The Penis Gemach

I originally wrote this post while I was still religious, and published it under a pseudonym on...

Aish Hatorah, Saviors of Souls

If one man can kill six million Jews, then one man can save six million Jews. That mantra,...